Wednesday, July 29, 2009

Jews beheading Gentile schoolgirls to shouts of "YHWH is great!" and 13,694 other acts of Judaic terrorism

Vapor. Fiction. Islamic fantasy.

The post title puts the lie to Muslim claims of moral equivalence.
Mohamed complains:
you claimed that it's false that Islam prohibited killing women and children . . . exceptional incidents in exceptional conditions
No, I pointed out that Muhammad changed [or ignored] the rules whenever it was to his advantage:
"The Prophet passed by me at a place called Al-Abwa or Waddan, and was asked whether it was permissible to attack the pagan warriors at night with the probability of exposing their women and children to danger. The Prophet replied, "They (i.e. women and children) are from them (i.e. pagans)." (Bukhari Volume 4, Book 52, Number 256).
Funny how many "exceptional conditions" Muhammad faced!

That poetess Asma bint Marwan with her nuclear-tipped verse would have oppressed and slaughtered thousands of Muslims with just one line!

Thank Allah for Umayr!

Mohamed continued:
About these texts in the Bible, Old Testament; We Muslims believe . . . The same messages of peace, love and forgiveness . . . we believe that such texts are made by Jewish rabbis who distorted and corrupted the Bible . . . So, these brutal commands in the Bible didn't came from God. Allah, Our Creator, The Most Merciful wouldn't order to kill infants and sucklings!
This is self-contradictory: You don't believe that YHWH gave Israel the command to complete the dispossession of Canaan (killing all who remained in the cities they approached), but you do believe that Allah commands, "kill the unbelievers wherever you find them" and "Fight against the People of the Book until they feel themselves subdued and pay the jizya" (Sura 9).

That's odd: You reject a one-time, one-place, one-target Divine judgment for great evil (including child sacrifice), but swallow whole open-ended, universal commands to enslave and slaughter all who refuse the "invitation" to Islam -- including women, children, old men, and trees, when necessary.

(A side note: We have the Bible Jesus used, and He said the Law and the Prophets "cannot be broken," so no, your scholars are wrong about the Bible being "corrupted."

That puts your prophet in a bad spot, doesn't it?)


As for your shaded attempt at tu quoque and false moral equivalence: Point out from the Biblical texts even one command for offensive warfare against all non-Hebrews to make the world Israel.

Find a report of Jews beheading Gentile schoolgirls to shouts of "YHWH is great!" then find another 13,694 acts of Judaic terrorism.

Then we'll have something to talk about.